December 15th, 2009
Publishers Weekly Have You Lost Your Mind? | HarperStudio
Publishers Weekly Have You Lost Your Mind? | HarperStudio.
I haven’t weighed in my own mind whether or not I find this offensive.
My first reaction was to see whether or not the “final word” person, the editor, is African-American.
He is.
Then I got to thinking… does it make a difference? Should this photo be “ok” because an AFAM editor gave it the go-ahead?
Would this photo have been hailed as a work of genius if the concept was touted and executed by a different photographer? Would people then have hailed it as creative genius?
Would black folks have cried afoul if this were the case?
How, exactly, is this offensive? I haven’t determined just yet, and I’m not sure if I will ever count this cover as offensive.